Originally Posted by: ocarlier That's awesome! I have started looking at ways to clean coins up - any one know if pumice would be any good?
For use in a rock tumbler? I would imagine pumice will be too soft/brittle and it will just break up into a floury gungy mess, a very small amount of crushed pumice (flour grade) might work on one of the burnishing cycles when used on rock but wouldn't use it with coins. The cheapest option is white (plain) aquarium gravel but I have found the commercially sold media to be much better and faster. I haven't heard of broken plate being used but if the pieces are small enough it should work, I'm also interested to see how it turns out!
The 2 sorts of tumbling media I use are Ceramic Pyramids and Stainless Steel Shot. This media can be brought from
http://www.rotorualapidary.co.nz/. I have just picked up the shot today to use on some of my worst coins and it is working well. The ceramic pyramids do an Ok job but are not as harsh and take longer. I haven't tried quartz rock yet but reckon the same will apply, apart from the fact that some sort of polishing compound will be needed on the last cycles after rounding off to get the pieces shiny. Pick below of the commercial media.